Oatmeal Cream Cookie Tin - 12 Count

These cookies deliver the familiar shape and concept of the childhood favorite—two soft oat-based cookies sandwiching a sweet cream layer—but with an upgraded ingredient list and bakery-fresh texture. The cookie itself uses brown sugar for depth and molasses notes, studded throughout with creamy white chocolate chips that soften into the dough. Each cookie stays genuinely soft rather than crisp, with a tender chew that holds together around the cream center.

The tin contains twelve individually wrapped sandwich cookies, each sealed to keep the cookies from drying out between servings. The wrapping makes them easy to stash in a bag, share without committing to the whole tin at once, or ration over a week without worrying about staleness. Milk Bar ships these ready to eat—no thawing, no warming, just open and serve.

Because these arrive baked and filled, they have a set shelf life that starts the moment they leave the kitchen. The individual wrapping extends freshness, but these are best eaten within a few days of arrival rather than stored long-term. The brown sugar base gives a deeper, less sweet profile than the bright-colored supermarket versions, and the white chocolate adds richness without cloying. They work as a desk-drawer snack, a packed lunch throwback, or something to set out when you need a dozen identical servings that feel a little more intentional than a supermarket sleeve.