Are all six cookies different flavors?

Yes. The tin includes one Compost, one Cornflake Chocolate Chip Marshmallow, one Confetti, one Triple PB, one Chocolate Chip N' Chunk, and one Oatmeal Cream cookie.

How are the cookies packaged inside the tin?

Each cookie is individually wrapped to preserve freshness and keep allergens separated. The Triple PB Cookie contains peanuts but stays sealed in its own wrapper.

How big are these cookies compared to store-bought?

Milk Bar cookies are bakery-sized, substantially larger and thicker than standard grocery-store cookies. These are full-size versions of the bakery's regular cookies, not miniature samples.

Does the tin need additional wrapping to give as a gift?

No. The tin is designed to be gift-ready as it arrives and requires no extra packaging or presentation.

Assorted Cookie Tin - 6 Count

The 3-second version

Six individually wrapped cookies, one of each signature flavor
Includes Compost, Cornflake Chocolate Chip, Confetti, and three more
Separate wrapping isolates allergens and preserves freshness
Only one of each flavor
Triple PB Cookie contains peanuts

Why it's on GiftsFeed

Six Milk Bar cookies, one of every signature flavor

Most sampler packs give you the bakery's safe bets—chocolate chip in three guises, maybe a sugar cookie. This tin includes the Compost cookie, the one with pretzels and potato chips baked in, and the Cornflake Chocolate Chip Marshmallow, the kind of recipe that only makes sense once you've tasted it. The variety is actual variety: cake-inspired, peanut butter forward, oatmeal cream nostalgia, and straight chocolate intensity. If you already know Milk Bar cookies skew unconventional and you want to figure out which unconventional suits you, this is the fastest route there.

Good gift when

People who want to try the full range before committing to a dozen
Anyone sending a thank-you or celebration treat without guessing flavor preference
Households where everyone fights over the last good cookie

Skip it if One cookie per flavor may not satisfy if you already know your favorite and want multiples

Specs

Count: 6 cookies, one of each flavor
Packaging: Individually wrapped in reusable tin
Allergen: Triple PB Cookie contains peanuts

What's included

Compost Cookie
Cornflake Chocolate Chip Marshmallow Cookie
Confetti Cookie
Triple PB Cookie
Chocolate Chip N' Chunk Cookie
Oatmeal Cream Cookie
Reusable tin

If you're giving it

No sizing to guess
Arrives ready to give

Note that one cookie contains peanuts, though it is individually wrapped.

The details

This tin delivers a sample of the entire Milk Bar cookie lineup in one package. You get six individually wrapped cookies, each representing a different flavor from the bakery's permanent menu. Included are the Compost cookie with its salty-sweet pretzels and potato chips, Cornflake Chocolate Chip Marshmallow for texture contrast, Confetti with its cake-inspired profile, Triple PB Cookie for peanut butter depth, Chocolate Chip N' Chunk for fudgy chocolate intensity, and Oatmeal Cream for nostalgic soft-baked appeal.

The individual wrapping keeps each cookie fresh and separates allergens—the Triple PB Cookie contains peanuts, but it stays sealed away from the others. Textures range from chewy to crispy to fudgy, and the tin itself is sturdy enough to reuse.

This format works whether you want to taste the full range yourself or let someone else choose their favorite. The tin requires no additional packaging and looks finished when it arrives. Each cookie is bakery-sized, substantially larger than a grocery-store version, and the variety means you're not committing to a single flavor profile before you know what you like.

Milk Bar

Assorted Cookie Tin - 6 Count

Individually wrapped cookies in a gift-ready tin, from compost to confetti

$28at milkbarstore.com

Quantity

Buy from Milk Bar

Ships and sold by Milk Bar. About this merchant

The 3-second version

Six individually wrapped cookies, one of each signature flavor
Includes Compost, Cornflake Chocolate Chip, Confetti, and three more
Separate wrapping isolates allergens and preserves freshness
Only one of each flavor
Triple PB Cookie contains peanuts

Questions

Are all six cookies different flavors?: Yes. The tin includes one Compost, one Cornflake Chocolate Chip Marshmallow, one Confetti, one Triple PB, one Chocolate Chip N' Chunk, and one Oatmeal Cream cookie.
How are the cookies packaged inside the tin?: Each cookie is individually wrapped to preserve freshness and keep allergens separated. The Triple PB Cookie contains peanuts but stays sealed in its own wrapper.
How big are these cookies compared to store-bought?: Milk Bar cookies are bakery-sized, substantially larger and thicker than standard grocery-store cookies. These are full-size versions of the bakery's regular cookies, not miniature samples.
Does the tin need additional wrapping to give as a gift?: No. The tin is designed to be gift-ready as it arrives and requires no extra packaging or presentation.