How should I store the truffles and cookies?

Keep the birthday cake truffles refrigerated until you are ready to serve them. The cookies can stay at room temperature in their tins once opened, or you can refrigerate them if you prefer a firmer texture.

Are all the cookies nut-free?

No. One variety—the Triple PB Cookie—contains peanuts. The other five cookies in the assortment do not, and each cookie is individually wrapped so you can easily separate them.

What does the birthday cake truffle actually taste like?

The truffles have a dense, moist cake center surrounded by a thick layer of vanilla-forward frosting. The flavor profile is sweet and celebratory, similar to the frosting on a classic birthday cake but more concentrated.

Can I choose which cookie flavors I receive?

No. The bundle includes a preset assortment of six cookie varieties: Compost, Confetti, Chocolate Chip N' Chunk, Cornflake Chocolate Chip Marshmallow, Triple PB, and Oatmeal Cream.

How long do the cookies and truffles stay fresh?

Both are baked and assembled fresh before shipping. The cookies will stay at peak texture for several days at room temperature in their tins, and the truffles should be eaten within a few days of arrival if refrigerated. Check the packaging for specific best-by guidance.

The Sweetie

The 3-second version

Twelve birthday cake truffles plus twelve cookies in six flavors
Every piece individually wrapped for freshness and easy sharing
Assortment spans chocolate chip, confetti, cornflake marshmallow, and more
One cookie contains peanuts
Truffles must stay refrigerated
Bold, indulgent flavors throughout

Why it's on GiftsFeed

Signature cookies and cake truffles bundled for sharing

Most bakery bundles force you to choose between a single flavor in bulk or a sampler with portions too small to share. This one solves that by pairing a full dozen truffles with a dozen cookies split across six recipes, so you get both depth and variety in quantities that actually work for a group. The individual wrapping means people can navigate around allergens or preferences without touching everything, and the mix of textures—creamy truffles, thick cookies with chunky add-ins—keeps each piece distinct. It is built for the moment when you need to please a table without knowing what everyone likes.

Good gift when

Anyone feeding a group with varied dessert preferences
People who want variety without assembling their own assortment
Fans of bold, frosting-forward sweets and thick cookies
Households where allergen labeling and individual wrapping matter

Skip it if You prefer subtle, understated desserts or need a completely nut-free selection—one cookie variety contains peanuts, and the overall flavor profile leans toward celebratory and rich.

Specs

Total truffles: 12
Total cookies: 12 (6 per tin)
Cookie varieties: 6 different recipes
Packaging: Individually wrapped
Allergen note: One cookie contains peanuts

What's included

1 dozen birthday cake truffles
2 assorted cookie tins with 6 cookies each
1 Compost Cookie
1 Confetti Cookie
1 Chocolate Chip N' Chunk
1 Cornflake Chocolate Chip Marshmallow Cookie
1 Triple PB Cookie
1 Oatmeal Cream Cookie

If you're giving it

No sizing to guess
Arrives ready to give

Individual wrapping and tin packaging make this ready to present or serve immediately upon arrival.

The maker

Milk Bar built its reputation on reimagining nostalgic American desserts with unexpected intensity and texture. The brand started in New York and became known for treats that amplify familiar flavors rather than refining them—think extra frosting, extra crunch, extra sweetness. This bundle reflects that approach, combining the brand's signature birthday cake truffles with a rotation of cookies that layer in pretzels, marshmallows, and other mix-ins designed to surprise. Everything ships fresh from the bakery, wrapped individually to preserve the textures that define each recipe.

The details

This bundle packs two dozen individually wrapped treats into one shipment: a full dozen birthday cake truffles and twelve cookies spanning six different recipes. The truffles arrive with the brand's signature vanilla-forward frosting flavor, while the cookie assortment rotates through varieties that include chocolate chip, confetti, cornflake marshmallow, oatmeal cream, and a triple peanut butter option. Each cookie comes sealed separately, which addresses both freshness and allergen concerns when one variety contains peanuts.

The format works well for situations where you need variety without committing to a single flavor. Because everything is wrapped individually, people can pick what appeals to them without handling the rest. The truffles lean sweet and celebratory; the cookies offer a broader range, from chocolate-heavy to marshmallow-studded. Together, the bundle covers enough ground to satisfy most preferences without requiring you to curate your own assortment.

Expect treats that lean toward indulgent rather than restrained. The birthday cake truffles carry the frosting-forward profile the brand is known for, and the cookies tend to be thick, with mix-ins like pretzels, chips, and marshmallows that add texture. This is not a subtle dessert selection. It is engineered for impact, with bold flavors and generous portions that make it clear these are occasion treats, not everyday snacks.

The tin packaging keeps cookies protected during shipping and stores neatly once opened. Truffles arrive chilled and should stay cold until you are ready to serve them. Everything is baked or assembled fresh before shipping, so flavors stay vivid and textures stay true to what the brand intended.

Milk Bar

The Sweetie

Twelve birthday cake truffles and a dozen individually wrapped cookies in six rotating flavors

$87at milkbarstore.com

Quantity

Buy from Milk Bar

Ships and sold by Milk Bar. About this merchant

The 3-second version

Twelve birthday cake truffles plus twelve cookies in six flavors
Every piece individually wrapped for freshness and easy sharing
Assortment spans chocolate chip, confetti, cornflake marshmallow, and more
One cookie contains peanuts
Truffles must stay refrigerated
Bold, indulgent flavors throughout

Questions

How should I store the truffles and cookies?: Keep the birthday cake truffles refrigerated until you are ready to serve them. The cookies can stay at room temperature in their tins once opened, or you can refrigerate them if you prefer a firmer texture.
Are all the cookies nut-free?: No. One variety—the Triple PB Cookie—contains peanuts. The other five cookies in the assortment do not, and each cookie is individually wrapped so you can easily separate them.
What does the birthday cake truffle actually taste like?: The truffles have a dense, moist cake center surrounded by a thick layer of vanilla-forward frosting. The flavor profile is sweet and celebratory, similar to the frosting on a classic birthday cake but more concentrated.
Can I choose which cookie flavors I receive?: No. The bundle includes a preset assortment of six cookie varieties: Compost, Confetti, Chocolate Chip N' Chunk, Cornflake Chocolate Chip Marshmallow, Triple PB, and Oatmeal Cream.
How long do the cookies and truffles stay fresh?: Both are baked and assembled fresh before shipping. The cookies will stay at peak texture for several days at room temperature in their tins, and the truffles should be eaten within a few days of arrival if refrigerated. Check the packaging for specific best-by guidance.