How long do these desserts take to thaw?

Both the cake and pie thaw in a few hours at room temperature or overnight in the refrigerator. Plan ahead if you want to serve them the same day they come out of the freezer.

Can I freeze these desserts after they arrive?

Yes, both desserts keep in the freezer for up to two weeks after arrival. This lets you serve them on different occasions or save one for later.

How many people does this bundle serve?

Each dessert serves six to eight people when sliced into standard portions. Together, the bundle provides enough for a larger gathering or multiple smaller occasions.

Do these desserts need to be refrigerated after thawing?

Both taste best at cool room temperature for serving, but store any leftovers in the refrigerator. The cake and pie will keep for several days once thawed and refrigerated.

The Icons

The 3-second version

Includes a six-inch birthday cake and full-size pie
Both desserts ship frozen and thaw in a few hours
Each serves six to eight people at standard portions
Ships frozen, requires freezer space
Both desserts must be used within two weeks of arrival
Thawing takes several hours before serving

Why it's on GiftsFeed

Birthday Cake and Milk Bar Pie bundled together

Most bakery bundles force you to pick multiples of the same thing or settle for a sampler of tiny portions. This pairs two full-size desserts with completely different uses: one is a proper layered cake for when the occasion calls for it, the other is a no-fuss pie that works any night of the week. You get both without paying for them separately, and because they ship frozen you can serve them days apart. It makes sense for anyone who wants a celebration dessert on hand but also needs something easier for regular rotation.

Good gift when

People who host often and want backups in the freezer
Anyone who wants both celebration and everyday dessert options
Households that go through sweets quickly
Fans of Milk Bar who want to try both signatures

Skip it if You prefer to choose a single dessert rather than committing to two different styles at once

What's included

6-inch Birthday Cake
Milk Bar Pie

If you're giving it

No sizing to guess
Arrives ready to give

Ships frozen in insulated packaging, ready to present on arrival.

The maker

Milk Bar built its reputation on desserts that break from bakery convention without losing sight of what makes sweets satisfying. The birthday cake became famous for its unpretentious layers and rainbow-flecked crumb, while the pie earned a following for its unconventional filling and toasted oat crust. Both desserts started in the bakery's New York kitchens and became signatures because they delivered on flavor without demanding reverence. This bundle packages both in their full-size forms, frozen at peak freshness and shipped ready to thaw and serve whenever the occasion calls for it.

The details

This bundle brings together two of Milk Bar's most celebrated desserts in a single shipment. You get a six-inch birthday cake studded with rainbow specks and the bakery's distinctive pie, both full-size and ready to slice.

The birthday cake arrives with Milk Bar's signature funfetti look and layered construction. The pie delivers the bakery's cult-favorite filling in a ready-to-serve round. Both desserts ship frozen and thaw to serving temperature in a few hours on the counter or overnight in the refrigerator.

Each dessert serves six to eight people when sliced into standard portions. The cake works for celebrations where candles and layers matter. The pie handles casual gatherings or weeknight treats where you want something special without ceremony.

Both desserts keep in the freezer for up to two weeks after arrival, so you can serve them on different days or save one for later. They both taste best at cool room temperature, which lets the textures and flavors come through fully. Serve the cake with a sharp serrated knife for clean slices through the layers. The pie cuts easily with a standard table knife once it has thawed.

Milk Bar

The Icons

Two signature desserts in one package, ready to serve

$105at milkbarstore.com

Quantity

Buy from Milk Bar

Ships and sold by Milk Bar. About this merchant

The 3-second version

Includes a six-inch birthday cake and full-size pie
Both desserts ship frozen and thaw in a few hours
Each serves six to eight people at standard portions
Ships frozen, requires freezer space
Both desserts must be used within two weeks of arrival
Thawing takes several hours before serving

Questions

How long do these desserts take to thaw?: Both the cake and pie thaw in a few hours at room temperature or overnight in the refrigerator. Plan ahead if you want to serve them the same day they come out of the freezer.
Can I freeze these desserts after they arrive?: Yes, both desserts keep in the freezer for up to two weeks after arrival. This lets you serve them on different occasions or save one for later.
How many people does this bundle serve?: Each dessert serves six to eight people when sliced into standard portions. Together, the bundle provides enough for a larger gathering or multiple smaller occasions.
Do these desserts need to be refrigerated after thawing?: Both taste best at cool room temperature for serving, but store any leftovers in the refrigerator. The cake and pie will keep for several days once thawed and refrigerated.