Do these need to be refrigerated?

The truffles hold their shape at room temperature for short periods, making them suitable for travel and storage in a cool, dry spot. For extended keeping, refrigeration helps maintain freshness.

What do the birthday cake truffles taste like?

The B'Day Truffles have a rich, sweet flavor reminiscent of classic birthday cake—vanilla-forward with a dense, cake-based texture rather than a traditional ganache center.

Are the cookie truffles made with actual cookie dough?

The Chocolate Chip Cookie Truffles are designed to capture the fudgy, dough-like texture and deep chocolate flavor of a fresh-baked cookie, formed into a truffle shape and coated for structure.

How big is each truffle?

Each truffle is bite-sized, typically one or two bites depending on preference. They're small enough to eat in one go but substantial enough to feel like a real dessert portion.

The Double Truffle

The 3-second version

Twenty-four truffles split between two signature flavors
Birthday cake and chocolate chip cookie varieties in one box
Bite-sized portions that hold their shape without refrigeration
Sweeter than dark chocolate truffles
Ships via mail, so delivery timing varies

Why it's on GiftsFeed

Two dozen bite-sized truffles in two signature flavors

Most truffle assortments give you minor variations on ganache—same texture, slightly different fillings. This one pairs two entirely different dessert concepts in truffle form: one tastes like birthday cake, the other like cookie dough studded with chocolate. If you've ever opened a mixed chocolate box only to find the same creamy center in six different shapes, this approach makes more sense. The two flavors are distinct enough that eating one doesn't make you tired of the other, and the bakery's reputation rests on nailing nostalgic American sweets rather than chasing European refinement. For someone who wants actual variety in a confection box, this delivers it.

Good gift when

People who want dessert variety without buying multiple boxes
Anyone who appreciates nostalgic American bakery flavors reimagined
Hosts looking for a shareable sweet that doesn't require plating

Skip it if The truffles are sweet and indulgent, so if you prefer dark chocolate or less sugary confections, this leans richer and more dessert-forward than European-style truffles.

Specs

Total Count: 24 truffles
Varieties Included: 2 flavors
Brand: Milk Bar

What's included

One dozen B'Day Truffles
One dozen Chocolate Chip Cookie Truffles

If you're giving it

No sizing to guess
Arrives ready to give

Ships in Milk Bar's signature packaging, ready to present on arrival.

The details

This assortment brings together twenty-four truffles in two distinct styles from the bakery known for reimagining American desserts. You get a dozen B'Day Truffles—rich, cake-based bites with birthday cake flavor—and a dozen Chocolate Chip Cookie Truffles that capture the fudgy, dough-forward character of a fresh-baked cookie.

Each truffle is sized for one or two bites, making the box easy to share or portion out over several days. The birthday cake version leans sweet and nostalgic, while the cookie variety offers deeper chocolate notes and a denser texture. Both are coated to hold their shape at room temperature, so they travel well and hold up without refrigeration for short periods.

The box arrives in Milk Bar's signature packaging, designed to protect the truffles in transit and present them without additional wrapping. The assortment works equally well as a centerpiece dessert, a contribution to a gathering, or a personal stash for when something sweet and substantial sounds right.

Because the truffles are pre-portioned and individually formed, they suit situations where plated dessert feels like too much effort but a single candy bar isn't quite enough. The two-flavor format lets you pick based on mood or share with someone whose tastes differ from yours without committing to a full box of one style.

Milk Bar

The Double Truffle

Classic birthday cake and chocolate chip cookie truffles from the cult bakery

$74at milkbarstore.com

Quantity

Buy from Milk Bar

Ships and sold by Milk Bar. About this merchant

The 3-second version

Twenty-four truffles split between two signature flavors
Birthday cake and chocolate chip cookie varieties in one box
Bite-sized portions that hold their shape without refrigeration
Sweeter than dark chocolate truffles
Ships via mail, so delivery timing varies

Cheaper alternatives

Questions

Do these need to be refrigerated?: The truffles hold their shape at room temperature for short periods, making them suitable for travel and storage in a cool, dry spot. For extended keeping, refrigeration helps maintain freshness.
What do the birthday cake truffles taste like?: The B'Day Truffles have a rich, sweet flavor reminiscent of classic birthday cake—vanilla-forward with a dense, cake-based texture rather than a traditional ganache center.
Are the cookie truffles made with actual cookie dough?: The Chocolate Chip Cookie Truffles are designed to capture the fudgy, dough-like texture and deep chocolate flavor of a fresh-baked cookie, formed into a truffle shape and coated for structure.
How big is each truffle?: Each truffle is bite-sized, typically one or two bites depending on preference. They're small enough to eat in one go but substantial enough to feel like a real dessert portion.