Greatest Hits Duo
The 3-second version
- Birthday Cake and Assorted Cookie Tin from Milk Bar
- Full-size layer cake with vanilla rainbow cake and birthday frosting
- Tin of individually wrapped cookies in assorted flavors
- Ships frozen; requires thawing time before serving
- Cookie assortment may vary from batch to batch
- Large format—meant for sharing or multiple servings
Why it's on GiftsFeed
Milk Bar's two most-loved treats in one birthday-ready bundle
Most bakery bundles are samplers. This pairs two full-size items: a whole cake and a tin of cookies, both in the recipes that built Milk Bar's reputation. It matters because you get enough to serve a group or stock the counter for days, not just a taste of each. The Birthday Cake is the same one sold in their shops, and the cookie tin holds individually wrapped pieces that keep well. For anyone who already knows they like Milk Bar or wants to make an impression without a special order, this delivers the two items people ask for most.
Good gift when
- Fans of Milk Bar who want both flagship items at once
- Anyone hosting a birthday or celebration without baking
- People who prefer treats that keep and can be portioned out
- Gift-givers looking for a recognizable bakery name
Skip it if This bundle is built for fans of sweet, nostalgic desserts with bold frosting and sprinkles. If you prefer subtle flavors, less sugar, or single-serving portions, it won't match your style.
What's included
- Birthday Cake (full-size layer cake)
- Assorted Cookie Tin
If you're giving it
- No sizing to guess
- Arrives ready to give
Ships frozen in branded packaging; thawing required before serving.
The details
This duo brings together the two items Milk Bar fans reach for most: a whole Birthday Cake and an Assorted Cookie Tin. The Birthday Cake is the signature layer cake that made the bakery famous, built with vanilla rainbow cake, birthday cake crumb, and birthday frosting. The Assorted Cookie Tin holds a selection of the bakery's best-known cookies, each baked to the chewy-crisp texture Milk Bar is known for.
Both arrive ready to serve. The cake comes as a full-size layer cake that serves a group, while the tin holds individually wrapped cookies that can be shared or saved. Together, they cover dessert for a party, a week of treats, or a gift that doesn't need explanation.
The Birthday Cake is the same recipe sold at Milk Bar locations, with layers of moist vanilla cake studded with rainbow sprinkles, separated by cake crumb for texture, and covered in the bakery's tangy-sweet frosting. The Assorted Cookie Tin typically includes favorites like Cornflake Chocolate Chip Marshmallow, Compost Cookie, and Blueberry & Cream, though the exact selection may vary.
Both items ship frozen with insulation and ice packs. The cake thaws at room temperature in about two hours or overnight in the refrigerator. Cookies can be eaten straight from the freezer or thawed for a softer bite. Once thawed, the cake keeps for several days covered at room temperature, and cookies stay fresh in their tin or sealed at room temperature for a week or more.
Birthday Cake and Assorted Cookie Tin arrive together for celebrations or everyday indulgence
Ships and sold by Milk Bar. About this merchant
Cheaper alternatives
Questions
- How long does it take for the cake to thaw?
- The Birthday Cake thaws in about two hours at room temperature or overnight in the refrigerator. Cookies can be eaten frozen or thawed in minutes.
- What cookies are in the Assorted Cookie Tin?
- The tin typically includes Milk Bar's most popular cookies, such as Cornflake Chocolate Chip Marshmallow, Compost Cookie, and Blueberry & Cream, though the exact selection may vary.
- How many people does the Birthday Cake serve?
- The Birthday Cake is a full-size layer cake that serves a group, typically eight to twelve people depending on slice size.
- How should I store these after they arrive?
- Once thawed, keep the cake covered at room temperature for several days or refrigerate for longer storage. Cookies stay fresh in their tin or a sealed container at room temperature for a week or more.
- Does this arrive ready to serve?
- Both items ship frozen and need to thaw before serving. The cake requires about two hours at room temperature, while cookies can be eaten straight from the freezer or thawed quickly.
No reviews yet.
The first one comes from someone who bought it here.
More like this
20% off26-27 Weekly Grid Planner
Love Is Blind x maxbone Walk Set
Donguri Lamp
Sold outLittle Dutch Wooden Activity Hexagon Cube - Safari Friends
Sun Shower™ Coverall Dog Rain Suit
Fixed Adamas® | Black Paracord | Drop-point
Sold outUSA Ti Pocket Pro Cerakote *Limited Release*
